Alexander McNabb

UAE To Block ‘Hate Movie’: The Right Approach?

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

The TRA (Telecommunications Regulatory Authority) has directed the UAE’s telcos, Etisalat and Du, to block access to the film trailer for ‘Innocence of Muslims’. The trailer has been the cause of widespread and often violent protests around the world which have led to over seventeen deaths.

I checked just before mid-day but YouTube access to the film trailer wasn’t blocked. Google has resisted suggestions it take down the content, although has supported legally backed blocking requests in Malaysia, Indonesia, Egypt, Libya and India.

It’s an unpleasant little film and, in my humble opinion, is quite clearly in contravention of Google’s guidelines, which allow it to block content if it constitutes ‘hate speech’. The film and its intentions are clearly hateful in the extreme. I for one would hate to be the person who decided this wasn’t hate speech, because they have seventeen deaths – and rising – on their hands.

But the film, judging by the trailer, is also clearly the result of a deranged mind. It is laughably acted, woefully directed and amateurish in the extreme. It’s quite, quite potty. However, it purports to depict the Prophet Mohammad, which is at the core of the anger the film has caused.

You can clearly hear dialogue spliced in, supporting the actors’ claims that the anti-Muslim content was jacked in at post production. The result is a school project gone wrong – but crucially, a film that has met the desires of its maker. Because, of course, we have that reinforcement of Islam as a violent, antipathetic religion – certainly at odds with my twenty six years’ experience of travelling, working and for the past twenty years living in the Arab World. And the many, more reasoned, online objections expressed by Muslims all over the world to the trailer have, of course, not made the headlines.

Is blocking it the answer? I suspect not. Supporting its takedown is one thing, but stopping people accessing content that is having such a profound effect on our world means stopping people being able to make up their own minds and make informed judgement while others around the world continue to enjoy that privilege. Even if that content is hateful to us.

4 Responses to UAE To Block ‘Hate Movie’: The Right Approach?

  1. Erik 24/09/2012 at 12:22 PM

    This video should not have been published on YouTube in the first place,a lot of people have clearly been deeply offended and it is indirectly the cause of many deaths.Isnt the fact that it is still available to be viewed and offend proof that it IS a Mormon/CIA production?!

  2. Matt J. Duffy (@mattjduffy) 20/09/2012 at 6:08 PM

    UAE To Block ‘Hate Movie’: The Right Approach? http://t.co/BhjGTIO9

  3. Sophie 20/09/2012 at 5:43 PM

    The movie may constitute hate speech but whatever the intentions, neither the makers of it nor Google have seventeen deaths on their hands, even if they knew violence was a likely reaction to the video. They didn’t hold a gun to anyone’s head and say ‘go on a murderous rampage or we’ll shoot your wife and kids’. The day that making a movie that deeply offends people’s religious sensibilities is considered to be an act of murder/manslaughter (which is what the term ‘blood on their hands’ implies) is the day that free speech dies. From their perspective they may believe that they are telling the truth about Islam, and they should not have to censor themselves, because as soon as you self-censor in response to violence (or likely violence) you have, in a sense, capitulated to it.

  4. (@MidEastPosts) (@MidEastPosts) 19/09/2012 at 10:19 PM

    #UAE To Block ‘Hate Movie’: The Right Approach? http://t.co/Iy3AVEVN #muslims #islam #telecommunications

You must be logged in to post a comment Login