Brotherhood’s Battle With Judiciary: ‘A Matter of Revenge’
The Constitutional crisis in Egypt between the Muslim Brotherhood president, Muhammad Morsi, and the thousands of judges in the Egyptian judiciary, according to Amr Moussa, derives from a misplaced desire for revenge on the part of the Brotherhood.
Under the regime of Hosni Mubarak, the Brotherhood was only semi-legal, and members were often imprisoned (Morsi himself was). Moussa, a former cabinet member under Mubarak who broke with the regime around 2000 and became secretary general of the Arab League, says it is wrong to think of Mubarak appointees on the bench as mere lackeys of the former regime. Many sought more judicial independence, and often gave Brotherhood members a break, he said.
The BBC reports that President Muhammad al-Morsi is attempting to persuade judges there to compromise with him on the issues of hiring and re-hiring.
Moussa said that the president’s proposed compromise should have been offered from the very beginning.
There is an argument that Morsi, who gained a slim mandate as president last June and operates in the absence of a lower house of parliament (elections are set for October) should just wait until there is a proper government next fall and work with elected representatives on judicial reform.
The president had announced that the mandatory retirement age for judges had been changed from 70 to 60 The judges protested that some quarter of sitting judges would thereby be forced out. Then Morsi, they argued, would use the vacancies as as a pretext to stack the courts with Muslim Brotherood judges. The Muslim Brotherhood has long been said to suspect that the judges are Mubarak appointees and that they might like to promote a counter-revolution with their decrees.
Related posts:
- The Egyptian Lesson: The People’s Voice Doesn’t Matter RAMZY BAROUD: It's a dismal, depressing conclusion to make following events over the past two weeks. But it's clear what 'democracy' means for Egyptians ...
- Ballot Box or Revolt: The Choice Facing Brotherhood JUAN COLE: The Muslim Brotherhood faces a choice. If they go one route it could lead Egypt into a period of profound and long-lasting devastation ...
- Football ‘Ultras’ At The Heart of Egypt’s Latest Unrest JAMES DORSEY: They're trying to maintain a balance but given the fact that the regime is increasingly painting them as Islamists how long can that last? ...
- Morsi’s Victory: But At What Cost to Egypt’s Future? JUAN COLE: A deeply polarized country must face the reality that Morsi and his Muslim Brotherhood cadre have scored an overwhelming victory. ...
- What Are the Egyptian Military Planning? JUAN COLE: Strange statements are emanating from Egypt's Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. What are they up to? ...
- Wasted Opportunities: Brotherhood Is ‘Egypt’s Tea Party’ JUAN COLE: President Morsi has no one to blame but himself. By imposing a 'Brotherisation' of Egyptian politics he has forced the opposition onto the streets. ...
by Juan Cole
Juan Cole is Richard P. Mitchell Collegiate Professor of History at the University of Michigan. For three decades, he has sought to put the relationship of the West and the Muslim world in historical context. He continues to study and write about contemporary Islamic movements, whether mainstream or radical, whether Sunni and Salafi or Shi`ite. He lived in various parts of the Muslim world for nearly 10 years.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login