Online or Behind Closed Doors: The Big Saudi Discussion
The real discussions are online, according to a piece in yesterday’s Saudi Gazette.
The article, by Laura Bashraheel, paints a picture of a young people who are taking advantage of “a manic side of Jeddah that is evolving” in order to discuss important issues online. She quoted a young Mahmoud Sabbagh as saying that he’s taken his thoughts to the Internet because the Jeddah Literary and Cultural Club was too suffocating. (Official Saudi book groups have to submit their discussion points to the government in advance.)
A guy named Ahmad (who wouldn’t provide his full name) further told Bashraheel that he believes Twitter has opened doors: “Now we can interact more freely and exchange ideas, books, events and articles on Twitter and then discuss them with all kinds of people.”
In some ways, sure.
However: 1) Ahmad wouldn’t give his name in the article, and 2) Hamza Kashgari is now in solitary confinement in a Riyadh prison for free discussion of ideas on Twitter.
So Twitter has its downsides, too. Ideas shared on Twitter, like the ones that landed Kashgari in prison, are instantly very, very public (and very easy to make into a viral campaign against the author).
Activist Waleed Abu Alkhair writes in the Washington Post today about a real-life weekly salon in his home, which seems in many ways like a better place to share ideas (at least, well, if you’re a man).
He writes: ” I started the salon after government and religious authorities clamped down on gatherings of liberal youth in cafes and bookstores in the wake of Hamza’s arrest, severely constricting the space for free expression in this city.”
Meanwhile, the Saudi pavilion at this year’s London Book Fair boasted loads of books, according to Saudi prince and UK ambassador Prince Muhammad bin Nawaf. Ahmed Al-Hamdan, chairman of the Association of Saudi Publishers, said Saudi participation is way better this year because they’ve got a whole 120 square meters.
But what’s there, in the “official” pavilion? If it’s similar to the official Saudi pavilions at this year’s Cairo and Abu Dhabi fairs, there’s a whole lot of flash and not much substance. After all, Saudi-owned Al Arabiya recently reported that “Saudi writers publish abroad to escape censorship.“
So where are Saudi’s “real” literary meet-ups? I don’t know (particularly as real is a stupid word here), but I imagine them to be in homes, in unofficial spaces, sometimes online, too; flourishing despite attempts to regulate them into disappearance.
- Crackdown on Omani Online Community SUSAN AL SHAHRI: A number of individuals have been arrested but it's not clear what they've done and what the boundaries actually are. ...
- Saudi Women: The Power & Limitation of Social Media MAHA AKEEL, CGNEWS: It's clearly enabled women in the Middle East in particular to express their views more vocally but there are limits to what social media can achieve in effecting real change. ...
- Saudi Authorities Crack Down on ‘Book Fair Louts’ CROSSROADS ARABIA: The Saudi Ministry of Culture and Information has taken a firm line on trouble-makers at the Riyadh Book Fair....
- Progress or Not? The ‘Digital Eid’ Has Arrived CROSSROADS ARABIA: It seems that no element of life is safe from the encroachment of social media - not even sacred Eid customs...
- Saudi Conservatives ‘Froth’ At Female College Visit AHMED AL OMRAN: It seems to have become a regular stop for foreign dignitaries visiting the Kingdom. But that hasn't stopped conservatives offence-ometer going off the scale...
- Saudi Draft ‘Anti-Terror Law’ Evokes Strong Response AHMED AL-OMRAN: A leaked draft of a proposed, new anti-terror law has been leaked to Amnesty International. A predictable storm has erupted. ...
M. Lynx Qualey is a writer and passionate reader based in Cairo, Egypt and is the author of Arabic Literature (in English), the go-to blog for non-Arabic readers wanting a deeper understanding of Arabic literature.