Oman and Censorship: The Line You Can’t Define
Oman’s National Human Rights Commission has come out against the online commentators and activists who have been irking the government to the point where there have been a significant number of arrests recently.
Also see: Crackdown on Oman’s Online Community
The Commission’s statement, linked here, is a model of clarity. For instance: “NHRC pointed out that there is a difference between the freedom of opinion as a right and the practice of this right in reality. The dividing line makes the practice of this right legal and going beyond it a crime punishable by the law. The rule in this issue is that the freedom of individuals stops when the freedom of other individuals starts.”
The Omani public prosecution issued a statement last week that clarified its position on the issue of opinion expressed online and “calls upon all citizens on the importance of following the legal methods and means for the expression of opinion in line with the legal concept for the freedom of expression.”
The problem is, of course, as Omani columnist Susan Mubarak points out in Muscat Daily, there is no official ‘line’ that defines quite where ” the freedom of individuals stops” and “the freedom of other individuals starts”. Her excellent piece on the issue is balanced by the Uriah Heep tones of the Oman Tribune.
Article 29 of Oman’s ‘Basic Statute of the State‘ guarantees “The freedom of opinion and expression thereof through speech, writing or other forms of expression is guaranteed within the limits of the Law.” Those limits are, of course, nowhere defined.
Further clarifying its statement, the NHRC said that “It affirmed that it supports the freedom of opinion, which seeks to achieve the public interests rather than those harming or insulting others.”
The ‘About Human Rights’ page on the NHRC’s lovely, retro-style website is “under construction”. You’d have thought it would have been 404, wouldn’t you?
(Update: I’ve just learned from @muscati that a female member of the NHRC has resigned from the commission as a result of its decision to make this statement.)
- Crackdown on Omani Online Community SUSAN AL SHAHRI: A number of individuals have been arrested but it's not clear what they've done and what the boundaries actually are. ...
- A Taboo Subject: The Desperate Plight of Domestic Workers in Oman SUSAN AL SHAHRI: I'm a proud Omani but the way in which my fellow country people treat domestic servants fills me with shame. We must change....
- Women’s Rights in Oman: Still Plenty To Do SUSAN AL SHAHRI: The 'To Do' list as far as women's rights in Oman is concerned is, unfortunately, long. ...
- The Positives of Being a Woman in Oman SUSAN AL SHAHRI: While it's been a mixed year for women globally there are many advantages to being a woman in Oman...
- New Urgency For Anti Cyber Censorship Day NASEEM TARAWNAH: We have seen just what happens at the hands of the Internet. We have witnessed the possibilities and seen them realized in countries like Tunisia and Egypt......
- Omani Bloggers: More Questions than Answers DHOFARI GUCCI: I'm not interested in being plucked out of my home in the middle of the night for a post I wrote two years ago. Must I go through every single blog post and...
This comment is published thanks to Alexander McNabb and his blog, Fake Plastic Souks. In addition to being a Director at Spot On, Alex is a radio pundit, writes columns in newspapers, and has recently finished his second novel, Beirut.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login