Joshua Maricich

A Divided Egypt: Outside Cairo Concerns Mount Over Tahrir Protests

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

As clashes in Cairo between security forces and demonstrators enter their fourth day, the death toll continues to climb and many Egyptians outside of the capital are shaking their heads in disbelief.

Here in Minya, some 200 km south of Cairo, citizens are following the violence in Tahrir Square with nervous skepticism. They fear that the clashes will disrupt the upcoming parliamentary elections that they view as an essential first step towards building a new Egypt.

Indeed, in Minya and elsewhere in Middle Egypt, the densely populated swath of country straddling the banks of the Nile between Beni Suef and Qena, the populace has been eagerly awaiting new elections. During the past three decades, Middle Egypt was marginalized by the Mubarak regime as it centralized power in Cairo. Thus, these elections offer a rare and welcome opportunity for the citizens of Middle Egypt to secure more equitable representation in the country.

Though Minya is not scheduled to vote for candidates running for the People’s Assembly until the third round of elections to be held on January 3, the city is already plastered with campaign banners and voters are impatient. Emad, a young activist, said, “We wish we could hold elections immediately, the sooner the better.” This is a popular sentiment on the streets of urban centers outside of the capital, where people feel that they are being held hostage by Cairenes’ demands that they neither fully understand nor support.

“Why are they protesting now?” pondered one police officer, who said that he was glad to have recently been reassigned from Cairo to Minya. “Why can’t they wait until after the election and then make noise if they don’t like the outcome?”

The frustration is even more pronounced in Upper Egypt, in particular in the tourist centers of Aswan and Luxor. In the past several months, the attack on the Israeli embassy, the riots in Imbaaba and Maspero, and the sporadic clashes between protesters and the military in Cairo have devastated the tourism industry upon which most of their citizens depend. It is difficult for them to get excited about the new Egypt when the so-called revolution is threatening their livelihoods.

So, while revolutionaries in Cairo are hesitant to accept the election process outlined by the Supreme Council for the Armed Forces, Egyptians outside the capital watch in fear, because it is they who have the most to gain or lose in the new Egypt. Along the over-populated and under-employed banks of the Nile, the citizens are desperate to step forward while their compatriots in Cairo, they say, seem intent on taking two steps back.

Joshua Maricich, an American writer and analyst, and Will Raynolds, an American architectural conservator, are sailing a twenty-four-foot traditional felucca over 800 miles along the Egyptian Nile in order to document how the Egyptian revolution has impacted citizens outside of the capital and to record their visions of the new Egypt. They are blogging at:

4 Responses to A Divided Egypt: Outside Cairo Concerns Mount Over Tahrir Protests

  1. watchful eye 27/11/2011 at 9:11 AM

    Why do they need to keep uprising? Serious? Maybe because they were promise civil rule in 6 months?…and I’ve seen it pushed as far back as 2013. Maybe because they were promised Maubarak would be dealt with in a quick manner and the military keeps pushing that back too not to mention that testimony has been taken and not shared with the people, the media or the lawyers envolved. Maubarak is sleeping in a comfy bed tonight with food and doctors at his whim while the people of Egypt are doing without….think about that!!! Maybe if the military would just do 1 thing they said they would, people would have trust to wait.

  2. I love Egypt 23/11/2011 at 6:57 PM

    There is also alot of people in Cairo feel for that as they are also greatly affected by lack of tourists and many work in places like hurhgada, sharm, luxor, the voice of the protesters does not always cover all the people as in any country in the world…….They should wait till all elections have been done and let the country stabilize and start to put foundations in to grow a better Egypt, but how can any party do this if they keep protesting as it means one step forward 10 back……

  3. Spirit 23/11/2011 at 12:28 AM

    Luxor is suffering. Its my adopted hometown and tourism for almost a year now has been minimal. It is affecting the local population intensely. Almost all of the town is dependent upon tourism in one form or another.
    Egyptians here are concerned that Cairo is yet again ignoring Upper Egypt, treating them as peasants and fellahin with no education or intelligence. They simply want to get on with the elections and move forward, but are not being allowed to do that.

  4. JCWS 22/11/2011 at 10:05 PM

    The general view from over here in Europe seems to be that the army control the country and any elections whilst that control is in place will be a sham. On that basis the re-emerging revolution/uprising is seen as extraordinary bravery in a just cause, and not in terms of pragmatic issues of ‘when is the right time …’
    Whatever the best time is to deal with the issue of the army, there is no doubt it is an issue and the bravery of the Egyptians in asserting this is a shot in the arm against complacency and absolutely inspirational. Given all they have achieved so far, the seeming impossible odds of displacing the military (and hasn’t that always really been the issue?) have with this new uprising shortened considerably. I wouldn’t bet against them…

You must be logged in to post a comment Login