Subway Ad: So Who’s ‘Civilised’ and Who’s ‘Savage’?
I tried hard to stay away from the controversy surrounding the YouTube trailer for the movie “Innocence of Muslims” insulting to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and triggering waves of violent protests in the Muslim world, often incited by fundamentalist regimes such as Iran’s.
And what vindicated my thinking was a Tweet I read this morning by Nadine Toukan (@nadinetukan). It said: “The biggest insult to Islam is calling a piece of utter rubbish an anti-Islam film. Stop injecting the kool-aid intravenously.”
But then comes along news of more inflammatory material to be publicized in the New York subway system next week…
The advertisement will read:
In any war between the civilized man and the savage, support the civilized man
Support Israel [wedged between two Stars of David]
I deem the ad offensive. Although I do not call for censoring it, I am offended because I know, First Amendment notwithstanding, it would never have passed scrutiny or been allowed had it called Israel “savage.”
This adds insult to injury after revelations about Republican presidential hopeful (God forbid!) Mitt Romney.
The disclosures were made on Monday and Tuesday by Mother Jones, which published exclusive video footage of Romney speaking to donors at a May 17 fundraiser.
Among other dreadful clips, Romney is seen responding to a question about the “Palestine problem.” Romney pontificated that peace in the Middle East is not possible and a Palestinian state is not feasible, telling donors Palestinians have “no interest whatsoever in establishing peace and that the pathway to peace is almost unthinkable to accomplish.” Mother Jones also published a full transcript of the Romney secret video today, Wednesday that you can read here.
I don’t know whether to laugh or cry, but all this brought to my mind former President George Bush’s famous 2001 catchphrase, “Why do they hate us?”
The New York Times article on Tuesday titled Ad Calling Jihad ‘Savage’ Is Set to Appear in Subway writes:
After rejecting the ads initially, then losing a federal court ruling on First Amendment grounds, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority said on Tuesday that the ads were expected to appear next week at 10 subway stations.
“Our hands are tied,” Aaron Donovan, a spokesman for the authority, said when asked about the timing of the ad…
The New York Times article continues:
Pamela Geller, the executive director of the American Freedom Defense Initiative, said in an e-mail Tuesday that transit officials in Washington were “kowtowing to the threat of jihad terrorism.” She added that recent events in the Middle East had not given her pause “for a second” about posting the ads in New York.
“I will never cower before violent intimidation, and stop telling the truth because doing so is dangerous,” she said. “Freedom must be vigorously defended.”
She added, “If someone commits violence, it is his responsibility and no one else’s.”
The transportation authority has said it did not try to block these ads because they did not meet the agency’s threshold for “demeaning” language, as the ad referring to a “savage” had.
Muneer Awad, the executive director of the New York chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said the ads were an attempt to “define Muslims” through hate speech.
“We’re encouraging American Muslims to go out there and define themselves,” he said.
Mr. Awad said the group had not called for the ads’ removal, though it has asked the transportation authority to redirect funds it receives for the ads to the city’s Human Rights Commission.
“It’s perfectly legal to be a bigot and to be a racist,” he said. “We want to make sure there’s a counter-voice.”
- ‘Inflammatory’ anti-Jihad ads hit NYC VIDEO: "Inflammatory" adverts equating Islamic jihad with savagery have been posted in New York City subway stations, causing controversy. ...
- Hate Ad Spray Can Protest: ‘It’s All About Mona’ ROB L. WAGNER: She seems to specialise in self-aggrandizing stunts that diminish the message and provide fodder for anti-Muslim parodies. ...
- ‘Hate Islam, Love Israel’: US Public Don’t Buy Message MAI ABDUL RAHMAN: The intention behind the vile subway ad campaign is clear - to drive a wedge between non-Islamic Americans and their Muslim co-citizens. ...
- The Islamophobe Industry: Big Growth in U.S. ROB L. WAGNER: In the United States 'Muslim' equals 'Terror' to a huge number of its citizens hence the increasing influence of Islamophobes...
- There’ll Never Be a ‘Right’ President for Palestine NADIA HIJAB, TABSIR: Palestinians have finally realised that they themselves will determine their own fate not some idealised notion of a U.S President. ...
- American Muslims: Same Concerns as Non-Muslims ROB L. WAGNER: It seems impossible for many Americans to view Muslims other than through a Middle East lens. ...
3 Responses to Subway Ad: So Who’s ‘Civilised’ and Who’s ‘Savage’?
You must be logged in to post a comment Login