Christina Hebert

Citizenship in the Gulf: Is It A Gift or A Right?

Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size Text Size Print This Page

Throughout the Gulf, from Kuwait to Qatar, citizens are justifiably proud of the progress their nations have made in the past few decades. Perhaps nowhere else in the world has a group of people risen so quickly, from dwellers of villages in the desert sands to denizens of skyscrapers that seem to touch the sky. The nations of the Gulf have achieved tremendous success in a very short time.

Within these rapidly evolving countries, certain social issues are rising to the forefront as each nation strives to define its place in the modern world. Residents of Gulf states have recently taken to social media to discuss such issues as how Westernized their nations should be, the amount of influence Islamists should have, the changing roles of women and men, and the invisible line that separates freedom of speech and protection from insults.

Perhaps one of the most contentious topics being discussed is the issue of “population imbalance”, i.e. the ratio of citizens to expat workers in Gulf nations, and the accompanying issue of who should be allowed to become a citizen. Passionate discussions on social media forums such as Twitter have offered an array of opinions on the subject, from Gulf citizens suggesting that all non-citizens should go home, to non-citizen residents saying they love their nation just as much as any citizen and they would fight and die for it.

A sensitive topic for many, population imbalance is a concern in the Gulf because citizens here are minorities in their own countries. Exact numbers are difficult to come by, but the ratio of citizens to expats reportedly ranges from approximately 1 to 3 in Kuwait to 1 to 7 in the UAE. Each Gulf nation has thousands of non-citizens, resident workers from places such as Jordan, Syria, Palestine, Egypt, India, Iran, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.

Who gets to be a citizen? Traditionally, citizenship in the Gulf has rested with the father, i.e. children of a citizen father automatically become citizens. Children of citizen mothers married to non-citizen fathers are not granted citizenship. And children of non-citizen parents are automatically non-citizens themselves, even if they were born in, and have lived their entire lives in the Gulf.

Issues of citizenship and naturalization have gained more attention recently, following the Arab Spring movements in the region. Some changes have already taken place. In 2011, the UAE granted citizenship to more than 1,000 children of women who are Emirati citizens married to non-Emirati men, and Bahrain granted citizenship to more than 300 children of Bahraini women with foreign husbands. These moves were widely praised. Still, these numbers are so low as to be almost negligible, and the measures do nothing to address the situation of residents who were born in Gulf nations but do not have at least one citizen parent.

Some Gulf nationals share the belief that, for their country to be successful in the future, its citizens should be of the same ethnic background, religious traditions and national origin. Yet the Gulf has never been 100% homogenous, and historic documents and photograph indicate that people from other parts of the world have lived and worked in the region for centuries.

It is understandable that Gulf nations would want to be careful about granting citizenship and residency. Imagine how much it would strain social resources to grant citizenship to all who wanted it! However, Gulf countries could also realize some potential benefits from initiating a naturalization program for some of their best and brightest non-citizen residents. Such a move could deepen ties between the Gulf and partner nations, enrich Gulf culture with top professionals from all over the world and offer young non-citizens something to aspire to.

Perhaps Gulf nations will consider expanding the definition of what it means to be an Emirati, Omani, Kuwaiti, Bahraini or Qatari by allowing a limited number of foreigners to become citizens. After all, a nation’s strength does not come from its homogeneity. The strength of a nation lies in its culture, in its ability to inspire loyalty and to absorb and unite diverse elements. The Gulf is as rich in this strength as it is in oil.

Christina J. Hebert is an English language teacher residing in the Gulf. Her Tweets have recently been featured in The Huffington Post and The National. An avid user of social media, she can be found on Twitter: @ChristinaHebert .

5 Responses to Citizenship in the Gulf: Is It A Gift or A Right?

  1. sara ahmed 11/06/2013 at 2:45 PM

    i personally dont agree that people accept to simply change their real identity and culture just for the sake of being part of the country their living in , for example i know a pakistani in nationality that lived in one of the gcc countries for less then 4 years and wants to apply to have the passport and also travels with that country number plate car just for them to believe that “this person” is a gcc citizen and ofcourse “this person” always consider them selves as a gcc when someone ask them about their home country i mean just by the look you can tell , that is defiantly not acceptable , its such a shame that people throw their identity so easily just to fit in.
    i wish they can make a law that nobody can drive a car abroad when they dont have the passport of the cars number plate , what a shameful thing to do

  2. (@mita56) (@mita56) 01/04/2012 at 1:25 PM

    Interesting post on citizenship on @MidEastPosts I would consider it if I had a choice.

  3. Mohammed Mirza 01/04/2012 at 8:48 AM

    I agree with your view that nation concept should be based on culture, but what in case if a state lacks to culture or identity without having a history to support its existence!

    The major problem lies with concept of citizenship in GCC that societies of these countries are tribal. The nature of tribal society is locked on itself and does not absorb others.

  4. (@zaksam) (@zaksam) 31/03/2012 at 9:42 PM

    ask the kids, the second generation of expats…”@MidEastPosts: Citizenship in the Gulf: Is It A Gift or A Right? ..”

  5. Faisal S. AlSabah (@fsalsabah) 31/03/2012 at 4:07 PM

    Interesting article. | Citizenship in the Gulf: Is It A Gift or A Right? – by @ChristinaHebert

You must be logged in to post a comment Login