Money Talks: Qatar’s WC Bid Fits SWF Strategy
Money talks. That is the inescapable conclusion from a closer look at Qatar’s successful bid for the 2022 FIFA World Cup and the relationship between sports investments by oil-rich nations and acquisitions by their sovereign wealth funds. The linkages do not constitute legal transgressions but raise moral and ethical questions, highlight loopholes in FIFA guidelines for World Cup bidders, and paint a picture of a distorted playing
field in which cash-rich authoritarian power constitutes a competitive advantage.
Flush with cash from its energy exports and determined to position itself as a world sports hub, Qatar spared no cost in its campaign to win the bid the World Cup. Recent research and media reports assert however a potential relationship between the votes of various FIFA executive committee members and Qatari investments and/or support for soccer in their home countries as well as a link between the soccer-related activities of its sovereign wealth fund, the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA).
Sponsorships and acquisition of clubs “not only improve the respective clubs’ finances, but could also whet their appetites for investing in national companies in the target markets. What is interesting is that these football investments appear to effectively stimulate, or go hand-in-hand with, other industrial investments,” says Javier Santiso, author of The Emerging World Champions, a report published by the Barcelona-based ESADE
Center for Global Economy and Geopolitics and former chief economist of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Development Center.
To be clear, the votes by FIFA executive committee members are secret and there is no evidence that Qatari investments and soccer activities influenced the way some members voted. Such activities provided that they do
not benefit committee members or their federations are allowed under FIFA rules. It is nonetheless reasonable to assume that such activity could influence how committee members cast their votes. Internal documents of
Qatar’s bidding committee obtained by The Wall Street Journal.
On at least one occasion, Qatari officials discussed circumventing a written FIFA request not to hold high-profile events during the FIFA World Cup, the Journal reported. It said that senior bidding committee executives discussed during a January 4, 2010 strategy meeting the need to improve Qatar’s standing within the world soccer community by helping South Africa’s poor during the 2010 World Cup. “If FIFA regulations prevent these initiatives then a way has to be found to do these under a different name (e.g. through the embassy or as the State of Qatar),” the Journal quotes minutes from the meeting as saying. Qatari executives say the committee ultimately backed away from the plan to ensure that its actions would not be misconstrued.
While Qatar has never published the total budget of its bid, just its budget for marketing and event-related spending matched or topped total expenditure of its competitors such as Australia which spent $45 million on its bid or the $10 million campaign cost of the United States.
Qatar’s Aspire Academy for Sports Excellence which is controlled by the ruling family last year added Thailand and Costa Rica, two nations with members on the FIFA executive committee, to its annual Aspire Football
Dreams tournament, the largest talent hunt in soccer history. Other countries represented on the committee – Paraguay, Cameroon, Ivory Coast and Nigeria already were included among the 16 countries participating in the
hunt for the next generation of world class soccer players. More than half a million kids born in the mid-1990s from hundreds of cities in Africa, Asia and Latin America compete to be one of 25 players accepted at Aspire’s training academies in Qatar and Senegal.
A 2009 Qatari bid document, reviewed by the Journal, lays out plans for grassroots soccer training in Nigeria and to “build a football academy in Thailand emulating the Aspire Football Dreams Academy in Senegal.” Disgraced Nigerian executive committee member Amos Adamu said this week that he was seeking to be reinstated after being suspended in November for three years following claims he had asked for money in exchange for his World Cup vote. Thai committee member Worawi Makudi is believed to have voted in favor of Qatar. Aspire has pledged to build a soccer academy in Thailand.
A FIFA investigation into allegations that Qatar conspired with Spain and Portugal to secure the support of the five Spanish and Portuguese-speaking members of the soccer world body’s 24-member executive committee for their respective 2022 and 2018 bids concluded that there were insufficient grounds for penal action. The relationship between Qatari soccer-related investments and activities and other commercial investments in the same markets is legal; it tracks similar operations by sovereign wealth funds in the Middle East and Asia. It is impossible to ascertain whether or not such activities played an indirect role in the thinking of FIFA executive committee members but they nonetheless constitute an interesting pattern.
A Qatari investment company linked to the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA) launched last May a $500 million fund to invest in Brazilian real estate. QIA’s investment arm, Qatar Holding, acquired a $2.72 billion convertible five percent stake in the Brazilian business of Spanish bank Santander. It was the Gulf state’s first major acquisition in Latin America. Similarly, Qatar is negotiating the purchase in Argentina of agricultural land worth at least $100 million as part of its effort to ensure the nation’s food security. Qatar has also made investments in Turkey’s finance, energy and health sectors.
In his report, EADES’s Santiso uses the Libyan Investment Authority (LIA), Libya’s sovereign wealth fund, as an example of the relationship between soccer and commercial investments. LIA, a major foreign investor in Italy with stakes in financial institutions Unicredit and Mediobanca, oil company ENI and aerospace group Finmeccanica, holds a 7.5% stake in Juventus, which is controlled by the Agnelli family, owners of FIAT.
“What is clear is that the interest in the Italian club went hand in hand with the wish of the sovereign wealth fund to become a stakeholder in different Italian multinationals. The appeal of national clubs and sports stars produce a greater appetite for other assets in host countries.” Santiso says.
- This post comes from a new blog by James M. Dorsey, The Turbulent World of Middle East soccer. Writes Dorsey: “This is a world in which the game is played as much on as off the pitch. Soccer is the only institution that rivals political as well as non-political Islam in creating alternative public spaces to vent pent-up anger and frustration. In various MidEast nations, soccer is the only non-religious, non-governmental institution capable of successfully taking a stand against militant Islamists or military and security dominated regimes. Soccer has its own unique thrill in the region – a high-stakes game of cat and mouse between enthusiasts and jihadists and a struggle for a trophy grander than the FIFA World Cup: the future of a region. This blog will explore the match that challenges the boundaries set by authoritarian regimes seeking to retain power at whatever price, thrives on the enlargement of goal posts imposed by globalization on governments and societies, defies gender and sexual discrimination, demands greater transparency and accountability and offers the disenfranchised a voice in an environment of forced silence and official misrepresentation.
- British Parliament Lashes Out At FIFA Handing of Qatari Bribery Claims JAMES M. DORSEY: The UK parliamentary call for an independent investigation of the alleged Qatari bribery follows a similar call by the German FA....
- FIFA Corruption Probe Set to Examine Qatar Bid JAMES M. DORSEY: The recently announced investigation by FIFA into allegations of past corruption will inevitably put Qatar 2022 in the spotlight again. ...
- Blatter Hints FIFA May Investigate Qatar Bid JAMES M. DORSEY: There's resentment against Qatar hosting the WC because its riches allowed it to spend far more than its competitors...
- FIFA Concedes Traded Votes in World Cup Bids JAMES DORSEY: If Blatter’s admission is correct, those votes would account for seven of the 12 votes that won Qatar its right to host the world’s biggest sporting event....
- Blatter U-Turn Sees Door Closed on FIFA Investigation of Qatar’s World Cup Win JAMES M. DORSEY: Sepp Blatter, a month after opening the door to an investigation of the Qatar's 2022 World Cup bid, has declared "case closed"....
- Worrying Times: FIFA Opens Door to Investigation of Qatar’s World Cup Bid JAMES M. DORSEY: In a worrying development for Qatar, the FIFA president has opened the door to a possible investigation into its successful World Cup bid....
The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer is the progeny of James M. Dorsey, a senior fellow at Nanyang Technological University’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies. Soccer in the Middle East and North Africa is played as much on as off the pitch. Stadiums are a symbol of the battle for political freedom; economic opportunity; ethnic, religious and national identity; and gender rights. Alongside the mosque, the stadium was until the Arab revolt erupted in late 2010 the only alternative public space for venting pent-up anger and frustration. Soccer has its own unique thrill – a high-stakes game of cat and mouse between militants and security forces and a struggle for a trophy grander than the FIFA World Cup: the future of a region.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login